Yuck. That’s my feeling towards all of the remaining candidates. Right off the bat, I want a strong border enforcement candidate and I’m SOL there. McCain says he’s that guy now, but he’s also the guy that tried to give 12 million illegal immigrants legal status, so I’m not very convinved on that front. The Democrats tend to take the view that as long as the immigrants are likely to vote for us, let them all in. So, that’s a loser issue for me.
My second issue would probably be the war and I suspect that none of these candidates are as different as they would like us to believe. They will all have to listen to the commanders on the ground and here the best-case/worst-case scenarios and decide. And, they will probably all reduce troop levels as a tactical necessity (we’re running out of them) and the decisions will be about how fast and how many get pulled. McCain will pull out the fewest and the slowest, probably Obama would pull out the most and the fastest with Hillary in the middle, but it will all be matters of degree, not radical change; I just can’t picture the field commanders saying a drastic pull-out would be good for the region and they will probably all be scared of us having to go back into a worse situation in the future, which would involve all the costs of mobilizing and returning instead of trying to secure it while we are already there.
I guess my third issue would be health care and that probably puts Hillary slightly ahead of Obama and Obama way ahead of McCain. Their plans on paper don’t count for nearly as much as their ability to actually get a proposal through congress. Which, ironically enough, is probably where McCain is far and away the strongest of the three. If he had a decent health plan, he could probably pass it because of his deep ties in congress. Out of the three, he is the only person who actually has experience passing major bi-partisan legislation. For all of Obama’s talk about a new bipartisan way of doing things, he has never worked with Republican leaders on anything and it remains to be seen if he really could. For Hillary, it remains to be seen if she would even try. She might accept failure if she can hammer the Republicans with it in the mid-terms to try and build a better congress for years 3 and 4. I suspect she has a tendency to think tactically that way, because of what they went through when congress shifted in Bill’s terms.
Let’s see, what else is there? Oh, yeah; the economy. I don’t believe presidents have diddly-squat to do with the overall economy, especially in this age of so many global influences, but I guess I would rate Hillary the best of the three in terms of talking about it. She knows the lingo and understands the concepts. The brutal reality here is that our next president will be taking over a country in a recession, with massive deficits and an ongoing war. Will they increase taxes? They probably should, because low-taxes at a time of war is historically stupid. However, higher taxes may deepen or prolong the recession. So, most likely all three will punt and run up bigger deficits to be cleaned up at a happier time by a different president.
My last big issue would be defense spending. The defense budget includes billions of dollars on stupid, unncessary and non-functional ideas. Missile defense doesn’t work and we’re more likely to be hit with a suitcase bomb than a missile. Nuclear submarines aren’t exactly the weapon of choice against Al Quaeda and we already have the most powerful air force in the world by a factor of 10, so to be building more fighters and bombers is a complete waste of money. But none of these candidates will touch defense spending with a 10-foot pole. In fact, they will probably increase it just to show how defense-friendly they are. At the very least, I wish they would redirect the money into projects with some practical value. Special forces, cyber-forces, cultural forces, law enforcement troops and other things useful in counter-terrorism/nation-building would make a lot more sense at this point.
So, it’s an incredibly exciting election cycle with 3 candidates that I dislike. It’s just a great round of play-offs in a sporting league when you don’t like any of the teams. Yip, yip, hooray….